Bay Shore, New York

Real Estate

Homes for Sale in Bay Shore, NY

Home for sale in Bay Shore, NY
Featured Listing

137 Main St, Bay Shore, NY

Bay Shore, NY
2 Bedrooms1 BathroomsVaries Sq Ft

Featured Agent — Bay Shore, NY

This Featured Agent Spot Is Available

Be the go-to local expert in Bay Shore, NY.

Claim your spot and get featured on this page. One agent per town — direct leads, no splits.

Claim This Town — $99/yr

VIP Buyer Program

Get First Access to Homes in Bay Shore, NY

Join our VIP buyer list and be the first to know when new listings hit the market in Bay Shore. No obligation — just early access.

Join VIP Buyer List
Bay Shore, New York community

Real Estate Market

Bay Shore Market Snapshot

Current market data for Bay Shore, New York.

$746,000Median Sale Price
44 daysAvg Days on Market
86Active Listings
$414Price per Sq Ft

Local Experts

Featured Agents in Bay Shore

Be the exclusive featured agent for Bay Shore, NY. One agent per market — direct buyer leads, no commission splits.

Available — Claim Now$99/yr

Your Name Here

Primary Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Claim Spot #1 in Bay Shore — $99/yr
Available — Claim Now$99/yr

Your Name Here

Secondary Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Claim Spot #2 in Bay Shore — $99/yr

Looking for homes nearby? Join our VIP buyer list for early access to new listings.

About Bay Shore

Living in Bay Shore, New York

Bay Shore is a community in Suffolk County, New York, offering a mix of residential neighborhoods, local amenities, and real estate opportunities. Part of the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA metro area. Search Your Town connects buyers, sellers, and local agents to help you find your perfect home here.

View Bay Shore Listings
Bay Shore, New York community

For Agents

Claim Bay Shore as Your Town

Become the exclusive featured agent for Bay Shore, NY. One agent per market. Direct leads. No commissions. Just $99/yr.

Search Your Town — Explore Local

SEARCH. LIVE. SHOP LOCAL.

New Jersey

VRI Homes — VRIHOMES.com

Lawrence Vecchio

55 West Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735

O: (800) 405-3914

NJ License #7871741

Florida

Search Your Town / Lawrence Vecchio

46 N Washington St Suite 9

Sarasota, FL 34236

800-531-2885

© 2026 Search Your Town | Lawrence Vecchio | All Rights Reserved